Even dumber than Mayor Bloomberg is Steve Chapman, a supposedly Conservative columnist, who is trying to differentiate himself from other Conservatives by adopting far out lefty ideas. In Repeal Religious Freedoms at ground Zero? Chapman offers an irrelevant analogy to set up a series of meaningless rhetorical questions.
Suppose there were a heavily Muslim neighborhood in New York, with mosques, religious schools and shops with meat prepared according to Islamic dietary rules. Suppose an evangelical church wanted to build a chapel there. And suppose local Muslims tried to block it as a flagrant insult to them.
Would Sarah Palin urge the church to retract this “unnecessary provocation” in the “interest of healing”? Would her followers? Or would they scorn this disparagement of Christianity and champion the religious freedom on which America was built?
You know the answer. But Palin is not a slave to intellectual consistency. Change the church to a mosque, and put it a couple of blocks from the site of the World Trade Center, and she suddenly loses all patience with the rights of religious believers.
For the analogy to hold, Chapman’s first paragraph would have to be modified slightly. Read more >













