When you are on the wrong road, you will never get to the right place, no matter how fast you walk. Bush’s road map to peace in the Middle East is the wrong road. It only addresses the territorial aspect of a broader conflict.
Enlightened Westerners like to pretend that the dispute was caused by an Israeli land grab and compounded by economic exploitation of the poor Palestinians. The State Department’s mantra, “poverty breeds terrorism”, has convinced many opinion makers that bliss is just a few Israeli concessions and wheelbarrows of American cash away.
The Arabs never refuse the cash, which makes it appear, to the casual observer, that progress is being made. However, the money is never enough. Palestinian lust for Israeli wealth can not be satiated short of a hostile takeover.
The truth is that the territory, from river to sea, simply can not be divided into two separate states that are each both secure and contiguous. If one is contiguous the other is, by definition, insecure.
There is but one solution to the territorial dispute. One side must leave.
Arab nature and the Jihad will be much more difficult to tackle.
In an article posted on the CHABAD website before the Gaza withdrawal, Rabi Dov Greenberg provided an excellent analogy to illuminate the conflict.
We’ve been reading about the “road map” to peace in the Middle East for many years. Anyone can see it hasn’t taken us very far. It’s been like trying to get to the Golden Gate Bridge in San Francisco using a map of Lower Manhattan. You can try harder, pray harder, and double your speed. But your efforts only succeed in getting you to the wrong place faster. The fundamental problem has nothing to do with traffic jams, diversions or delays; it has everything to do with using the wrong map.
For over a decade, Israel has navigated tirelessly to achieve peace using the Oslo map, which was built on this premise: Assuage the other side’s grievances–end the occupation; give the Palestinians land, armed forces, their own state–and peace will follow. Hence in 1993, Israel brought the PLO out of exile and gave it recognition, international legitimacy, governmental autonomy and authority over 98% of the Palestinian population.
Where has this map brought us? In the past decade, terrorism has increased dramatically. Eleven years ago, Yitzhak Rabin, in his historic speech on the White House lawn, spoke of a future in which mothers no longer wept for sons lost in battle. But the weeping has not ended; it reached a deafening crescendo. Terrorists have killed more Israelis in the eleven years since Oslo began in 1993 than in the 45 years of Israel’s existence before that.
Obviously we’ve been using the wrong map to move us toward peace. Is there an alternative?
Read more >